As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Full details on our Affiliate Disclosure page.
The Resistance: Avalon and Secret Hitler are two of the most popular hidden-role games for big groups. Both split the table into a good team and a hidden evil team, and both end with arguments about who lied. The differences are in how evidence appears, how games end and how each theme lands with your group. Here is how Avalon vs Secret Hitler compares.
Best first hidden-role game: The Resistance: Avalon
Quests, votes and a dramatic Merlin guess at the end, for five to ten players. It costs about $30.
Price band: $20–$30 (about $30) · Check today’s price on Amazon
Avalon vs Secret Hitler at a glance
| Avalon | Secret Hitler | |
|---|---|---|
| Players | 5 to 10 | 5 to 10 |
| Teams | Loyal servants of Arthur vs minions of Mordred | Liberals vs fascists |
| How the good team wins | Three successful quests, then survive the Merlin guess | Five liberal policies or the Hitler player is executed |
| How the evil team wins | Three failed quests or guess Merlin correctly | Six fascist policies or Hitler elected chancellor late in the game |
| Play time | About 30 minutes | About 45 minutes |
| Price | about $30 | about $45 |
How Avalon plays
A leader picks a team to go on a quest, and everyone votes to approve or reject it. Players on the quest secretly play success or fail cards, so a single fail can sink it. Merlin knows who is evil but must hide that knowledge, because if the good team wins, the Assassin gets one guess at Merlin to steal the game. That final moment gives Avalon a memorable ending almost every time.
How Secret Hitler plays
Each round a president nominates a chancellor, and the table votes. The president draws three policy cards, discards one and passes two to the chancellor, who enacts one. Because the deck has more fascist policies, a bad policy might be bad luck or a lie, and that doubt fuels the debate. Fascist policies unlock presidential powers, including investigating a player or executing one.
Key differences
- Evidence: Avalon's failed quests give hard information. Secret Hitler's random policy draws give plausible excuses, so there is more bluffing.
- Player elimination: Secret Hitler can execute players, who then sit out. Avalon keeps everyone in the game.
- Theme: Avalon uses King Arthur legends. Secret Hitler's political theme is a deal-breaker for some groups, so ask first.
- Endings: Avalon builds to the Merlin guess. Secret Hitler can end suddenly when Hitler is elected chancellor.
Avalon or Secret Hitler: which to buy
Buy Avalon if you want a shorter, cleaner game where everyone stays involved and the theme suits any crowd. Buy Secret Hitler if your group loves bluffing and debate, does not mind player elimination and is comfortable with the theme. Many groups own both and alternate. Avalon also builds on the earlier Resistance game; our Avalon vs Resistance guide explains the difference.
Special roles and replay value
Avalon ships with optional characters that change each game. Percival knows who Merlin is but may be fooled by Morgana, Mordred is hidden even from Merlin, and Oberon is an evil player who does not know his teammates. Adding one or two of these roles keeps the game fresh for a long time. Secret Hitler has fewer roles, but the presidential powers change with player count, so a seven-player game feels quite different from a five-player game.
Best group size for each
Both games technically start at five, but they come alive with seven or more. Avalon handles ten players well because quests stay short and votes move quickly. Secret Hitler at ten can slow down when the table debates every policy, so keep a gentle timer for discussion. With exactly five players, Avalon is usually the smoother choice, since one bad Secret Hitler draw can swing the game early.
Tips for a first game of either
Both games need a confident narrator for the eyes-closed setup, so pick someone who has read the rules. Play a short first game with the basic roles, then add special roles once everyone understands how votes work. Remind new players that lying is part of the game, and set a friendly tone so nobody takes accusations personally.
The bottom line on these hidden-role games
For most groups, Avalon is the safer first purchase. It is quicker, easier to teach and has a satisfying ending. Secret Hitler is the better pick for groups who want maximum bluffing and are fine with its theme. If you already own Secret Hitler, our games like Secret Hitler list has more options.
Avalon vs Secret Hitler FAQ
Is Avalon or Secret Hitler better for beginners?
Avalon. The rules are shorter, games are quicker and nobody is eliminated.
How many players do Avalon and Secret Hitler need?
Both need at least five players and support up to ten.
Can kids play Avalon?
Avalon's fantasy theme suits teens well. Check the box age rating and your group before choosing either game.
