As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Full details on our Affiliate Disclosure page.
New Phone, Who Dis? turns the funniest part of group chats into a card game. A judge reveals an awkward incoming text, everyone else answers from a hand of reply cards, and the judge keeps the message card for the funniest answer. If your group has worn out the deck, these games like New Phone Who Dis keep the same quick judge-and-reply laughs, from a direct texting twin to comics, memes and magnet poetry.
Closest match to New Phone, Who Dis?: Think You Can Text?
Same idea, fresh texts: match a reply card to an awkward incoming message for a rotating judge. It costs about $20.
Price band: $10–$20 (about $20) · Check today’s price on Amazon
1. Think You Can Text? — groups who want the same game with new cards
Players: 2 to 10, adults · Price band: $10–$20 (about $20) · Pick for: Groups who want the same game with new cards · See Think You Can Text? on Amazon
Think You Can Text? is the nearest relative on the shelf. A rotating judge reads an incoming text situation card and says who it is from, then everyone else plays the reply card they think fits best. The judge picks a winner and that player scores the round. The box holds 500 cards, 150 text situations and 350 replies, so it lasts a long time before jokes repeat.
If you liked how quickly New Phone, Who Dis? teaches, this one needs no extra explanation at all.
Skip it if: you want something that feels different; this is the same format with new jokes.
2. Joking Hazard — darker humor and comic fans
Players: 3 to 10, ages 18+ · Price band: $20–$30 (about $25) · Pick for: Darker humor and comic fans · See Joking Hazard on Amazon
Joking Hazard comes from the Cyanide & Happiness webcomic. Instead of a single reply, you build a three-panel comic: the deck and the judge set up the first two panels, and everyone races to supply the punchline panel. Because the cards are pictures rather than words, the humor lands differently every time, and the art does half the work.
We compare it with another classic in Cards Against Humanity vs Joking Hazard.
Skip it if: your group dislikes edgy or crude jokes; this deck is proudly offensive.
3. Ransom Notes — creative groups who like to write their own answers
Players: 3 or more (teams for bigger groups), adults · Price band: $30+ (about $40) · Pick for: Creative groups who like to write their own answers · See Ransom Notes on Amazon
Ransom Notes hands every player a pile of tiny word magnets. A prompt card asks for something like a breakup text or an excuse to your boss, and you build the answer from the words in front of you. The limited vocabulary is the joke: you know exactly what you want to say and have to get there with whatever words you have.
Our Ransom Notes rules guide covers timing and scoring.
Skip it if: you want a fast game; building answers takes longer than playing a card.
4. Incohearent — loud guessing rounds
Players: 2 or more (played in teams), ages 17+ · Price band: $10–$20 (about $16) · Pick for: Loud guessing rounds · See Incohearent on Amazon
Incohearent, also from Relatable, trades judging for racing. A card shows a string of gibberish, and saying it out loud slowly reveals a real phrase. The first player to crack it wins the card. It is a good change of pace after a long run of judge games because everyone plays at once.
Skip it if: you want the slow-burn laughs of a judge picking favorites.
5. Cards Against Humanity — the classic fill-in-the-blank crowd
Players: 4 or more, ages 17+ · Price band: $20–$30 (about $29) · Pick for: The classic fill-in-the-blank crowd · See Cards Against Humanity on Amazon
Cards Against Humanity is the game that made this whole style famous. A judge plays a black card with a blank, everyone answers with a white card, and the judge picks the funniest pairing. If your friends love New Phone, Who Dis? but have never played the original, start here; if they have, the expansions keep it fresh.
See which Cards Against Humanity expansions to buy before adding more cards.
Skip it if: you have already played it to death; pick Joking Hazard or Ransom Notes instead.
Text and reply party games compared
| Game | Players | How you answer | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| New Phone, Who Dis? | 3 or more | Reply card to a text | about $19 |
| Think You Can Text? | 2 to 10 | Reply card to a text | about $20 |
| Joking Hazard | 3 to 10 | Comic panel | about $25 |
| Ransom Notes | 3 or more | Build it from word magnets | about $40 |
| Incohearent | 2 or more | Race to decode gibberish | about $16 |
| Cards Against Humanity | 4 or more | Fill in the blank | about $29 |
What makes New Phone, Who Dis? work
The game borrows a format everyone already knows. You do not need to explain what a text message is or why an answer is funny out of context. That means new players are laughing in the first round, which is rare for party games. Every pick above keeps that low barrier: one judge, a hand of options, and a winner every round. What changes is the medium, from comics to magnets to tongue-twisting gibberish.
Still need the original? New Phone, Who Dis? (about $19) plays with three or more, and our New Phone, Who Dis? rules walk through a full round.
Choosing your next adult party card game
- Same game, new jokes: Think You Can Text?
- Visual humor: Joking Hazard.
- Writers and wordplay fans: Ransom Notes.
- Everyone plays at once: Incohearent.
- First-timers to the genre: Cards Against Humanity.
For a wider list of judge-style games, see our best games like Cards Against Humanity guide.
Games like New Phone Who Dis FAQ
What game is most like New Phone, Who Dis?
Think You Can Text? It uses the same incoming-text and reply-card format with a rotating judge.
Is there a version of this game that works for two players?
Think You Can Text? lists two to ten players, and Incohearent works with two because it is a race rather than a vote.
Are these games family friendly?
No. Every pick here is aimed at adults. For mixed ages, look for family editions or a word game such as Ransom Notes with the spicier words removed.



