Concordia and Brass: Birmingham game boxes side by side, full products shown on white — Concordia vs Brass

Concordia vs Brass: Birmingham (2026): Which Strategy Game?

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Full details on our Affiliate Disclosure page.

Concordia vs Brass: Birmingham (2026): these are two of the most respected economic strategy games you can buy, and they often end up on the same wish list. Both are about building a network and making money, but they feel very different at the table. Concordia is calm and elegant, with one card played per turn. Brass: Birmingham is a tense economic engine where loans, shared resources and timing decide everything. This guide helps you pick the right one.

Quick verdict for most groups: Concordia

If you are choosing one, Concordia is easier to teach, plays up to five and still rewards experienced players. It costs about $46.

Price band: $30+ (about $46) · Check today’s price on Amazon

Concordia and Brass on Amazon

Both are long-term favorites for strategy fans.

  • Most approachable: Concordia — card-driven trade for 2 to 5 (about $46)
  • Deepest economy: Brass: Birmingham — industrial strategy for 2 to 4 (about $64)

Concordia and Brass: Birmingham compared

Concordia Brass: Birmingham
Players 2 to 5 2 to 4
Game length About 90 minutes 60 to 120 minutes
Designer Mac Gerdts Gavan Brown, Matt Tolman and Martin Wallace
Core idea Play cards to grow a Roman trade network Build industries and links across two eras
Luck None beyond the card market Card draws
Money Simple coins Loans, income track and debt
Best for Clean, approachable strategy Deep economic tension

Concordia in a nutshell

Every player starts with the same hand of personality cards. On your turn you play one: the Architect moves your colonists and lets you build houses, the Prefect makes a province produce goods, the Mercator lets you trade, the Diplomat copies another player’s last card and the Tribune returns all your played cards to your hand. You can also spend a turn buying a new card from the market. The game ends when the market empties or someone builds their last house, and each card’s god then multiplies a type of scoring, such as houses in cities or the number of provinces you reach.

How Brass: Birmingham plays

In Brass, each player takes two actions a turn (one in the very first round) by discarding cards. You build industries such as cotton mills, manufacturers, potteries, coal mines, iron works and breweries, link towns with canals in the first era and railways in the second, take loans and sell goods to merchants. Coal and iron are shared, so building next to an opponent’s mine helps both of you. At the end of each era, your flipped industries and links score points, which means the order you build in is crucial.

Is Concordia or Brass easier to learn?

Concordia. The rules are short and the cards explain themselves after a round or two. Brass: Birmingham has more rules to absorb, including how coal and iron are consumed, how beer works for selling and how the board resets between eras. Most groups need one full game before Brass clicks.

Which has more player interaction?

Brass: Birmingham. The shared coal, iron and beer, along with the fight over good locations, mean other players constantly affect your plans. Concordia’s interaction is gentler: you compete for good cards and cities, and the Diplomat lets you copy someone else, but there is no direct blocking of supplies.

Which works better for two players?

Both work well with two. Brass: Birmingham uses a separate part of the map at two players to keep it tight. Concordia’s board has two maps, and the smaller Italia side on the back is a good fit for two or three players, which is why it is often recommended for couples who love strategy.

How scoring works in each game

Concordia saves almost all scoring for the end. Every personality card you bought is tied to a Roman god, such as Vesta for your money, Jupiter for houses in non-brick cities, Saturnus for the provinces you reach and Mercurius for the types of goods you produce. The cards you choose during the game decide what counts for you at the end, so two players can chase very different plans.

Brass: Birmingham scores twice, after the canal era and after the rail era. Only industries that have been flipped by selling goods or using their coal, iron or beer score points, along with links next to valuable locations. At the end of the canal era, the lowest-level industries are removed from the board, so the map changes in the middle of the game.

Do Concordia and Brass hold up over many plays?

Both are games people play for years. Concordia’s card market comes out in a different order every time, and the map expansions add new regions. Brass: Birmingham is deep enough that experienced players keep finding new ways to use the shared economy, which is why it sits near the top of strategy rankings.

Concordia or Brass: our pick

  • Pick Concordia if you want an elegant strategy game for up to five that you can teach in 15 minutes.
  • Pick Brass: Birmingham if your group loves money management, shared economies and two-hour games.
  • Own both if you play heavy games often. They are different enough that neither replaces the other.

See how each compares with another classic in Concordia vs Castles of Burgundy and Brass vs Power Grid, or browse the best economic board games.

Concordia vs Brass FAQ

Is Brass: Birmingham harder than Concordia?

Yes. Brass has more rules and more ways to make costly mistakes, while Concordia’s rules are short.

Which game plays more people?

Concordia supports up to five players. Brass: Birmingham supports two to four.

Is there luck in Concordia or Brass?

Concordia has almost none. Brass has card draws that limit where you can build, but skilled play wins out.

Back to blog