Pick Your Poison: How to Play and Why It Is a Party Hit

What Is Pick Your Poison?

Pick Your Poison is a hilarious “would you rather?” style party game designed to spark laughter, heated debates, and unforgettable memories. Players create bizarre and awkward scenarios, forcing everyone to pick between two outrageous choices.

It is a perfect icebreaker for parties, game nights, and any gathering where you want to get people laughing and talking.

How to Play Pick Your Poison

Setting up the Game

• • Players: 3 or more
    
    
  • Setup: Shuffle the deck of Poison Cards (green and purple). Each player gets a set of voting cards.
    
    

Game Objective

The goal is simple: create hilarious, impossible scenarios and force your friends to choose. Players score points by guessing how the group will vote.

Step-by-Step Gameplay

Choose a Judge

Each round, one player acts as the Judge. They draw four Poison Cards — two green and two purple.

Create the Scenarios

The Judge selects one green and one purple card to create two different dilemmas. These are read aloud to the group.

Examples:

• • "Have spaghetti for hair" or...
    
    
  • "Never be able to use the internet again"
    
    

Discuss and Debate

Players ask the Judge clarifying questions about each Poison. The Judge must answer creatively, making things even more chaotic and fun.

Vote Anonymously

Players secretly vote for the option they would rather endure.

Reveal and Score

Everyone reveals their votes simultaneously.

• • If you voted with the majority, you score a point.
    
    
  • The Judge scores if they predicted the majority.
    
    

Variations of Pick Your Poison

Pick Your Poison NSFW Edition

This adults-only version adds spicy and shocking dilemmas, perfect for bachelorette parties or late-night game nights.

Pick Your Poison Family Edition

A cleaner, family-friendly version with equally hilarious but more appropriate dilemmas for all ages.

Why Pick Your Poison Is a Party Favorite

It Sparks Outrageous Conversations

Pick Your Poison encourages players to justify ridiculous choices, leading to hilarious debates and endless laughter.

It Is Quick to Learn and Play

New players can join instantly. No complicated rules, no long setup — just shuffle and start laughing.

It Works for Any Group Size

Whether you have four friends or a whole house party, Pick Your Poison easily fits any group without slowing down the fun.

Tips for Making Pick Your Poison Even Better

Be Creative When Answering Questions

The more absurd your clarifications, the better the debates will be. Don't be afraid to get weird!

Add Drinks or Dares

For adults, wrong guesses can lead to silly dares or drinks to turn up the energy.

Encourage Wild Explanations

After voting, players should explain their choice. The crazier the reasoning, the bigger the laughs.

Where to Buy Pick Your Poison

Pick Your Poison is available at major retailers including Amazon, Walmart, and specialty game shops. Choose the edition that matches your crowd — Classic, NSFW, or Family.

Pick Your Poison Guarantees a Night to Remember

Pick Your Poison stands out for its simple rules, endless creativity, and ability to get everyone laughing within minutes. Whether you want to break the ice at a party, create hilarious memories with friends, or simply try something new, Pick Your Poison is a must-have.

Get ready to laugh, debate, and defend the ridiculous. Pick your poison — and let the games begin!

Grab Pick Your Poison on Amazon!

FAQs About Pick Your Poison

1. What ages is Pick Your Poison appropriate for?
   The Family and Classic Editions are appropriate for ages 8+, while the NSFW Edition is for adults 17 and older.
2. How long does a typical game last?
   Games usually last 30 to 45 minutes, depending on the group size and how much time you spend debating.
3. How many players can play?
   Pick Your Poison is great for 3 to 10 players, but it works even with larger groups.
4. Can I mix different versions of Pick Your Poison?
   Yes, mixing the NSFW and Classic cards creates even crazier and more unpredictable games.
5. Is there an online version of Pick Your Poison?
   Currently, Pick Your Poison is a physical game only, but you can find ways to improvise online play.
6. Are you an Amazon Associate, and what does that mean?
   Pick Me Up is a part of the Amazon Associate program. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases. When you click on links to various merchants on this blog, this can result in us earning a commission.