What Not to Talk About on a First Date: Conversational Pitfalls to Avoid

What Not to Talk About on a First Date: Conversational Pitfalls to Avoid

First dates are all about first impressions—and what you say matters just as much as how you say it. While great conversation can spark chemistry, the wrong topic can kill the vibe before dessert even hits the table.

Knowing what not to talk about on a first date is just as important as knowing what to say. This guide breaks down the topics to avoid, why they’re risky, and how to redirect the conversation when things get awkward.

Let’s make sure your first date leaves them excited for a second—not looking for the exit.

Why the Wrong Conversation Can Derail a First Date

A first date isn’t an interview, therapy session, or debate—it’s an opportunity to connect. You’re not trying to unpack your entire life story or prove a point. You’re simply trying to see if there’s chemistry and curiosity worth exploring.

Oversharing or misjudging topics can:

  • Create discomfort or tension

  • Make you seem emotionally unavailable or defensive

  • Shut down natural back-and-forth conversation

  • Distract from building actual connection

That’s why it’s smart to avoid certain subjects, especially early on.

What Not to Talk About on a First Date

Below are the most common conversation traps and why you should steer clear of them.

1. Exes and Past Relationships

Talking about your ex on a first date is a fast track to awkwardville.

Why It’s a Red Flag:

  • It signals you might not be over them

  • It shifts focus away from the present

  • It can make your date feel like a rebound or comparison

Instead, keep the spotlight on what you’re looking forward to—not what went wrong before.

2. Politics and Religion

Even if these topics matter to you deeply, they’re highly personal and potentially polarizing.

Why It’s Risky:

  • It can lead to heated debate before trust is established

  • It may reveal dealbreakers too early without context

  • You risk reducing each other to labels instead of individuals

Save these conversations for when you’ve built rapport and mutual respect.

3. Money, Salary, and Financial Status

Unless you’re trying to sound like a job recruiter, skip questions about earnings or spending.

Why To Avoid It:

  • It can come off as shallow or materialistic

  • It puts unnecessary pressure or comparison into the dynamic

  • Finances are a second- or third-date conversation—maybe

Instead of talking dollars, ask about passions or long-term dreams.

4. Health Problems and Trauma

Everyone has a story—but the first date isn’t the time to dive into heavy emotional territory.

Here’s Why:

  • Vulnerability is good, but too much too soon feels like oversharing

  • You may unintentionally shift the date into therapist mode

  • It can feel emotionally overwhelming

Keep things light and positive. There will be space to share deeper experiences—just not during appetizers.

5. Complaining About Life, Work, or Others

No one wants to feel like they’re on a date and listening to a rant.

Why Negativity Doesn’t Work:

  • It drains the energy from the conversation

  • It can signal a pessimistic mindset

  • It puts pressure on your date to “cheer you up”

Talk about what excites you or what you enjoy doing—those are better indicators of compatibility anyway.

6. Talking Too Much About Yourself

Yes, you want to be open—but don’t turn the date into a monologue.

Why It’s a Turn-Off:

  • It feels one-sided and dismissive

  • Your date doesn’t get a chance to share

  • You might miss subtle cues about their interests

Balance is key: listen as much as you talk, and show genuine curiosity.

7. Sex, Intimacy, and Physical Preferences

Bringing up sexual topics too early can feel pushy, objectifying, or just plain uncomfortable.

Why This Backfires:

  • It signals you're not interested in more than physical connection

  • It can make your date feel pressured or unsafe

  • It skips emotional connection in favor of surface-level attraction

Flirting is fine—crude or overly forward comments? Not so much.

8. Overly Personal Probing Questions

Asking about someone’s childhood trauma, fertility plans, or family dysfunction isn’t cute—it’s intrusive.

Avoid Asking Things Like:

  • “Why are you still single?”

  • “Do you want kids, like, now?”

  • “Are your parents divorced?”

  • “What happened with your last breakup?”

If it sounds like something you’d ask after months of dating—save it for then.

9. Talking About Future Weddings, Babies, or Moving In

Even if you’re dating with long-term intentions, don’t fast-forward to the future on day one.

Why It’s Premature:

  • It can feel intense or presumptive

  • It adds pressure to a lighthearted moment

  • It may send your date running for the hills

Focus on whether you enjoy each other today—the future can come later.

10. Too Many “Interview” Questions

“What do you do?” “Where are you from?” “Where did you go to school?”—sure, they’re standard, but don’t turn the date into a fact-finding mission.

Why It Falls Flat:

  • It doesn’t spark connection, just data points

  • It feels robotic and rehearsed

  • It leads to surface-level answers

Ask more open-ended questions that invite storytelling, not stats.

How to Gracefully Redirect the Conversation

Even if an awkward topic pops up, you don’t have to panic. You can pivot without making things weird.

Here’s How to Shift Gears:

  • Use humor. “Okay, enough of the serious stuff—what’s your guilty pleasure TV show?”

  • Ask something light. “So what’s a random fun fact about you?”

  • Own it. “That got heavier than I meant! Let’s lighten the mood a bit.”

Your date will appreciate your awareness—and your effort to keep things enjoyable.

Stick to What Builds Chemistry, Not Barriers

When it comes to what not to talk about on a first date, the rule is simple: avoid anything that feels like pressure, a judgment, or a therapy session.

You’re not here to solve problems—you’re here to share laughs, stories, and maybe spark something meaningful. Let curiosity, playfulness, and mutual interest guide your conversation—not interrogation or oversharing.

And if you want a fun, lighthearted way to kick off the conversation? Bring a cheeky icebreaker game like the Pick Me Up Party Game on Amazon. It’s full of flirty, unexpected prompts that take the pressure off and turn first-date awkwardness into connection.

FAQs About What Not to Talk About on a First Date

Can I talk about my ex if they ask?

It’s better to steer the conversation away. A simple, “It ended for good reasons, but I’m focused on now,” is usually enough.

Is it okay to talk about serious topics if the vibe feels right?

Yes—but let it happen naturally. Gauge their interest and comfort level before diving in.

What if my date brings up one of these taboo topics?

Handle it with kindness. Redirect gently or set a boundary if it feels necessary.

Are there any topics that are always safe?

Yes—travel, hobbies, pop culture, food, and funny stories are generally great first-date territory.

What if I accidentally overshare?

Own it with humor and pivot: “Okay, that was deeper than I meant! Let’s talk about something lighter—what’s your go-to comfort movie?”

Back to blog

Introducing: Pick Me Up–The New Pickup Line Card Game

Pick Me Up is a card game that's fun, flirty, and kinda dirty. Play this at your next game night with friends and turn cheesy pickup lines into hours of flirtatious fun! Click the button below to order now!

Pick Me Up–Now Available!

Pick Me Up is a question and response party game that turns cheesy pick up lines into hours of flirtatious fun. Get flirty with friends, make your crush blush, and practice your pickup lines before you make a fool of yourself at the bar.

What's inside your box:

😇 5 Consent Cards
🍆 60 Sultry Scenario Cards
🍑 300 Provocative Pickup Line Cards
💦 Totally Unnecessary Instructions
🤫 My Phone Number

BUY NOW